The Nissan Elgrand is a popular choice for families and those needing a spacious and comfortable vehicle. Choosing the right year is crucial to avoid potential problems and ensure a reliable ownership experience. This guide will help you navigate the different generations and models of the Elgrand to find the best fit for your needs.
Nissan Elgrand Generations: A Quick Overview
The Nissan Elgrand has gone through multiple generations, each with its own set of strengths and weaknesses. Understanding these differences is key to making an informed decision. Let's delve into which years offer the best value and reliability, and which ones might present more challenges.
Nissan Elgrand Model Year Comparison Table
| Model Year | Key Features & Improvements | Potential Issues & Considerations |
|---|---|---|
| E50 (1997-2002) | First generation, Affordable, Simple mechanics, Available in 2WD and 4WD. | Rust, Particularly in coastal regions, Engine wear on higher mileage examples, Basic safety features compared to later models. |
| E51 (2002-2010) | Second generation, More luxurious interior, Improved safety features (ABS, airbags), Powerful VQ35DE engine option, Increased fuel consumption. | Timing chain issues (VQ35DE), Electrical problems (especially with the infotainment system), Suspension wear due to vehicle weight, Higher running costs. |
| E52 (2010-Present) | Third generation, Modern design, CVT transmission (fuel efficiency focused), Advanced safety features (lane departure warning, adaptive cruise control), More compact exterior dimensions. | CVT transmission reliability (requires regular maintenance), Some reports of oil consumption issues with the QR25DE engine, Complex electronics can be expensive to repair. |
Detailed Explanations: Breaking Down the Generations
E50 (1997-2002): The Original Elgrand
The E50 marked the beginning of the Elgrand dynasty. These models are appealing due to their affordability and relatively straightforward mechanics. They are easier to work on compared to later generations. The availability of both 2WD and 4WD configurations makes them versatile. However, be wary of rust, especially if the vehicle has spent time near the coast. Engine wear is also a concern on higher-mileage examples, and the safety features are basic by today's standards. Thorough inspection for rust is paramount before purchase.
E51 (2002-2010): The Luxurious Upgrade
The E51 represents a significant step up in terms of luxury and features. The interior is noticeably more refined, and safety is improved with the inclusion of ABS and airbags. The VQ35DE engine provides ample power, making it a comfortable cruiser. However, this generation is known for potential timing chain issues, particularly with the VQ35DE engine. Electrical problems, especially with the infotainment system, are not uncommon. The weight of the vehicle also leads to suspension wear, and fuel consumption is higher than the E50. Consider a pre-purchase inspection by a mechanic familiar with the VQ35DE engine.
E52 (2010-Present): The Modern Minivan
The E52 boasts a modern design, improved fuel efficiency (thanks to the CVT transmission), and advanced safety features such as lane departure warning and adaptive cruise control. The more compact exterior dimensions make it easier to maneuver in urban environments. However, the CVT transmission is a potential weak point and requires regular maintenance. There have been reports of oil consumption issues with the QR25DE engine. The complex electronics can also be expensive to repair. Ensure the CVT transmission has been properly maintained with regular fluid changes.
Specific Problem Areas and What to Look For
Beyond the general considerations for each generation, here's a deeper dive into specific problem areas:
- Rust (E50): Pay close attention to the undercarriage, wheel arches, and sills. Look for bubbling paint or signs of previous repairs.
- Timing Chain (E51 VQ35DE): Listen for a rattling noise, especially on startup. This could indicate a worn timing chain.
- Electrical Issues (E51): Test all electrical components, including the infotainment system, power windows, and door locks.
- Suspension Wear (E51): Check for excessive body roll when cornering and listen for clunking noises from the suspension.
- CVT Transmission (E52): Ensure the transmission shifts smoothly and doesn't exhibit any slipping or hesitation. Check the service history for CVT fluid changes.
- Oil Consumption (E52 QR25DE): Monitor the oil level regularly and be aware of any blue smoke from the exhaust, which could indicate oil burning.
The Best Years: Recommendations
Based on reliability, features, and value, here are some recommended years:
- E50 (1999-2002): If affordability is your primary concern and you're willing to accept the limitations of an older vehicle, a well-maintained E50 from the later years of production can be a good option. Focus on finding a rust-free example with a good service history.
- E51 (2008-2010): The later E51 models benefited from some improvements and refinements. They offer a good balance of luxury, performance, and reliability. Look for a model with a well-documented service history and evidence of timing chain maintenance.
- E52 (2013-2016): These years represent a sweet spot in the E52 generation, offering a good blend of modern features, improved reliability (compared to the earlier E52 models), and reasonable pricing. Prioritize models with documented CVT transmission maintenance.
Years to Potentially Avoid (or Approach with Caution)
- Early E51 Models (2002-2004): These models are more prone to timing chain issues and electrical problems.
- Early E52 Models (2010-2012): The early E52 models had some initial teething problems, including CVT transmission concerns.
Buying Tips for a Nissan Elgrand
- Pre-Purchase Inspection: Always get a pre-purchase inspection from a qualified mechanic who is familiar with Nissan Elgrands.
- Service History: Review the service history carefully to check for regular maintenance and any major repairs.
- Test Drive: Take the vehicle for a thorough test drive, paying attention to the engine, transmission, suspension, and brakes.
- Check for Rust: Inspect the vehicle carefully for rust, especially in areas prone to corrosion.
- Negotiate Price: Be prepared to negotiate the price based on the condition of the vehicle and any potential repairs that may be needed.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the most reliable Nissan Elgrand generation? The later E51 models (2008-2010) and mid-range E52 models (2013-2016) are generally considered the most reliable.
Are Nissan Elgrands expensive to maintain? Maintenance costs can be higher than some other minivans, especially for the E51 and E52 generations due to their complex electronics and specific engine concerns.
What should I look for when buying a used Elgrand? Check for rust, engine issues (timing chain on E51, oil consumption on E52), CVT transmission maintenance (E52), and electrical problems.
Is the CVT transmission in the E52 reliable? The CVT transmission requires regular maintenance (fluid changes) and can be a potential weak point if neglected.
Are Elgrands good for long trips? Yes, Elgrands are known for their comfortable ride and spacious interior, making them well-suited for long trips.
Conclusion
Choosing the right year of Nissan Elgrand can significantly impact your ownership experience. By understanding the strengths and weaknesses of each generation, carefully inspecting potential purchases, and prioritizing models with good service histories, you can find an Elgrand that provides years of reliable and comfortable transportation. Consider the later E51 models (2008-2010) or mid-range E52 models (2013-2016) for a good balance of features and reliability.