The Audi S5 represents a sweet spot in the Audi lineup, offering a blend of performance, luxury, and style. Choosing the right year of S5 can be tricky, as each generation and model year has its own strengths and weaknesses. This guide aims to provide a comprehensive overview of the best and worst years of the Audi S5, helping you make an informed decision when purchasing this iconic sports coupe or convertible.
Audi S5: Model Year Overview
| Model Year | Generation | Key Features/Concerns |
|---|---|---|
| 2008-2012 | B8 (First Generation) | Pros: Naturally aspirated 4.2L V8 engine, hydraulic steering, classic Audi design. Cons: High fuel consumption, potential timing chain issues, older technology. |
| 2010-2016 (Sportback) | B8.5 (Facelifted First Generation) | Pros: Available as a Sportback, updated interior, improved fuel economy compared to pre-facelift V8. Cons: Potential for carbon buildup on the 3.0T engine, some electrical gremlins. |
| 2013-2017 | B8.5 (First Generation Facelift) | Pros: Supercharged 3.0L V6 engine, improved fuel economy, updated styling, available with S-Tronic dual-clutch transmission. Cons: Supercharger whine can be loud, potential for carbon buildup, S-Tronic transmission can be jerky at low speeds. |
| 2018-Present | B9 (Second Generation) | Pros: Turbocharged 3.0L V6 engine, improved performance and fuel economy, modern technology, refined interior. Cons: Electric power steering lacks feel, some reports of turbocharger issues, potential for water pump failure. |
| 2020-Present (Facelift) | B9.5 (Second Generation Facelift) | Pros: Updated styling, improved infotainment system, available mild-hybrid system. Cons: Continued concerns about electric power steering feel, potential for water pump failure. |
| 2019 | B9 (Second Generation) | Pros: Turbocharged 3.0L V6 engine, improved performance and fuel economy, modern technology, refined interior. Cons: Electric power steering lacks feel, some reports of turbocharger issues, potential for water pump failure. |
Detailed Explanations
2008-2012 (B8 First Generation): Naturally Aspirated V8 Era
The initial run of the Audi S5 featured a naturally aspirated 4.2-liter V8 engine, a true gem for enthusiasts who appreciate the linear power delivery and distinctive exhaust note. The hydraulic steering provided excellent feedback, making for an engaging driving experience. However, this generation suffers from higher fuel consumption compared to later models and is prone to timing chain issues, which can be a costly repair. The technology is also dated compared to newer cars.
2010-2016 (Sportback B8.5 First Generation Facelift): Practicality Meets Performance
The introduction of the Sportback variant added a layer of practicality to the S5, offering increased cargo space and rear passenger room. The facelifted models also received interior updates and improved fuel economy, but the 3.0T engine can be susceptible to carbon buildup, a common issue with direct-injection engines. Keep an eye out for potential electrical gremlins, as some owners have reported minor issues.
2013-2017 (B8.5 First Generation Facelift): Supercharged V6 Power
Audi replaced the V8 with a supercharged 3.0-liter V6 engine in the facelifted B8.5 models, offering a better balance of performance and fuel efficiency. The S-Tronic dual-clutch transmission provided quick and precise shifts, although it can be jerky at low speeds. Carbon buildup remains a concern, and the supercharger whine can be quite noticeable.
2018-Present (B9 Second Generation): Turbocharged and Technologically Advanced
The second-generation S5 moved to a turbocharged 3.0-liter V6 engine, further improving performance and fuel economy. The interior was completely redesigned with modern technology and a more refined feel. However, the electric power steering lacks the feedback of the hydraulic systems in earlier models, and there have been reports of turbocharger issues and potential water pump failures.
2020-Present (B9.5 Second Generation Facelift): Refined and Updated
The facelifted B9.5 models received updated styling and an improved infotainment system. Some models also feature a mild-hybrid system for enhanced fuel efficiency. Despite the updates, the electric power steering feel remains a common complaint, and the potential for water pump failure persists.
2019 (B9 Second Generation): The Sweet Spot?
The 2019 model year often stands out as a good balance. It has the benefits of the B9 generation - the improved performance and economy of the turbo V6, the modern tech, and the updated interior - but it's also a bit older, meaning potentially lower prices and more time for any initial production kinks to be ironed out. While it still shares the concerns about steering feel and potential water pump issues with other B9 S5s, it can be a compelling option for buyers looking for a modern S5 without the newest-model premium.
Frequently Asked Questions
-
Which Audi S5 has the best engine sound? The 2008-2012 models with the naturally aspirated 4.2L V8 engine offer the most desirable exhaust note.
-
What is the most reliable Audi S5 year? The 2013-2017 models with the supercharged 3.0L V6 engine are generally considered more reliable than the V8 models, but proper maintenance is crucial.
-
Are there any common problems with the Audi S5? Common issues include timing chain problems (2008-2012), carbon buildup (3.0T engines), and potential water pump failures (2018-present).
-
Which Audi S5 offers the best fuel economy? The 2018-present models with the turbocharged 3.0L V6 engine provide the best fuel economy.
-
Is the Audi S5 expensive to maintain? The Audi S5 can be expensive to maintain, especially older models, due to the cost of parts and specialized labor.
-
Is the S-Tronic transmission reliable? The S-Tronic transmission in the B8.5 S5 is generally reliable, but requires regular maintenance and can be jerky at low speeds.
-
What should I look for when buying a used Audi S5? Check for maintenance records, signs of carbon buildup, timing chain noise (V8 models), and turbocharger issues (2018-present). A pre-purchase inspection by a qualified mechanic is highly recommended.
Conclusion
Choosing the best Audi S5 depends on your priorities. If you value the sound and feel of a naturally aspirated V8, the 2008-2012 models are appealing, but be prepared for higher running costs. For a balance of performance and efficiency, the 2013-2017 supercharged V6 models are a good choice. The 2018-present turbocharged models offer modern technology and improved performance, but the electric power steering may not appeal to all drivers. Ultimately, careful research and a thorough inspection are essential to finding the right Audi S5 for you.